Gas vs. Electric Fireplaces: Which is Right for Your Wisconsin Home?

As Wisconsin homeowners seek warmth and ambiance during the state’s long, cold winters, fireplaces remain a popular home addition. But the age-old question lingers: should you go with a gas fireplace or an electric one? Whether you live in Wausau or elsewhere in Wisconsin, choosing between these two heating options requires a balance of practical needs, budget, aesthetics, and home setup. In this blog, we’ll explore both options in detail to help you make the best choice for your home.

Gas Fireplaces: Efficiency with a Classic Touch

A gas fireplace installation is a popular choice for many Wisconsin residents, especially those who love the look and feel of a traditional fire without the hassle of chopping or storing wood. Gas fireplaces use either natural gas or propane as a fuel source and are known for producing real flames, which offer an authentic fireplace experience. They can be vented through an existing chimney or direct-vented through an exterior wall, making them flexible for both older homes and modern constructions.

One of the main advantages of a gas fireplace in colder climates like Wausau is its powerful heat output. Gas units can produce more British Thermal Units (BTUs) than electric models, making them effective supplemental heaters during frigid Wisconsin nights. Many models come with adjustable flame settings and thermostatic controls, giving homeowners the ability to fine-tune the temperature and appearance of the fire.

Gas fireplaces are also incredibly convenient. With the press of a button or flick of a remote, you can enjoy instant warmth. There’s no need to deal with ashes, wood smoke, or extensive cleanup. Routine maintenance, however, is essential. Annual inspections are recommended to ensure safe operation, proper ventilation, and clean burners. Carbon monoxide detectors are a must-have in homes with gas appliances.

Installation costs for gas fireplaces can vary widely depending on the complexity of the job. If you already have a gas line and a suitable location, the process is relatively simple. But if gas lines need to be extended or venting systems installed, the upfront investment can be significant. Still, many Wisconsin homeowners find that the charm and heating performance of gas fireplaces make them well worth the cost.

Electric Fireplaces: Modern Simplicity and Versatility

Electric fireplaces have surged in popularity in recent years, and for good reason. They offer unmatched convenience, affordability, and style flexibility. Unlike gas models, electric fireplaces don’t require venting or fuel lines, making them perfect for apartments, condos, and homes where structural modifications aren’t ideal.

These fireplaces work by using LED lights and mirrors to simulate flames while a built-in heater provides warmth. Though the flames aren’t real, modern electric fireplaces have come a long way in mimicking the natural flicker and glow of fire. Some models even include crackling sound effects for added ambiance.

Electric fireplaces are generally easier and less expensive to install compared to gas units. In many cases, installation is as simple as plugging the unit into a standard electrical outlet. Wall-mounted, freestanding, and built-in designs are available, providing ample flexibility for homeowners looking to match their fireplace to their interior design.

One of the greatest appeals of electric fireplaces in Wisconsin homes is their energy efficiency for smaller spaces. While they don’t produce as much heat as gas fireplaces, they’re ideal for zone heating—warming the room you’re in without wasting energy heating the entire home. This can help reduce heating bills during the shoulder seasons or milder winter days.

Maintenance is virtually non-existent with electric models. There are no chimneys to sweep, gas lines to inspect, or soot to clean. And since there are no real flames, they are safer in households with young children or pets. However, it’s worth noting that electric fireplaces depend entirely on electricity, meaning they won’t function during a power outage—something to consider during Wisconsin’s occasional winter storms.

Comparing Installation, Costs, and Long-Term Value

When deciding between gas fireplace installation and electric fireplace options, understanding the full scope of initial and ongoing costs is essential. Gas fireplaces typically have a higher upfront cost due to the complexity of installation. Running gas lines, constructing a firebox, and setting up venting can add several thousand dollars to the price tag. Depending on the type and brand, expect to spend between $2,000 to $5,000 or more for a complete gas fireplace setup in Wisconsin.

On the other hand, electric fireplaces are much more affordable. Units start as low as a few hundred dollars, and installation costs are minimal if any. Built-in models can cost more but still generally stay below the price of gas units. Over the long term, electric fireplaces also tend to be cheaper to operate, especially in homes where gas is expensive or unavailable.

However, gas fireplaces often provide greater resale value, especially in regions like Wausau, where buyers value high-performance heating. The realism of a gas fire and the substantial heating capacity can be attractive selling points. That said, the sleek design and low-maintenance appeal of electric models can also attract modern-minded buyers who prioritize ease of use and energy efficiency.

Environmental and Safety Considerations for Wisconsin Homeowners

When evaluating fireplaces for your Wisconsin home, it’s important to factor in environmental impact and safety. Gas fireplaces burn cleaner than wood, producing fewer pollutants and particulates. But they still rely on fossil fuels, contributing to greenhouse gas emissions. Natural gas is considered a cleaner-burning fuel, but its extraction and distribution carry environmental consequences.

Electric fireplaces, by contrast, produce zero emissions at the point of use. Their environmental impact is directly tied to the source of your electricity. In Wisconsin, a growing portion of electricity comes from renewable sources such as wind and solar. Using an electric fireplace powered by renewable energy is one of the cleanest ways to enjoy the comfort of a fire.

Safety is another critical area to compare. Both gas and electric fireplaces are safer than traditional wood-burning fireplaces, which can emit smoke and pose fire hazards if not properly maintained. Gas fireplaces do carry a small risk of gas leaks and carbon monoxide exposure, which is why regular inspections and functional CO detectors are necessary.

Electric fireplaces, in contrast, are incredibly safe. Their surfaces remain relatively cool, and many come with automatic shut-off features to prevent overheating. This makes them particularly well-suited for homes with elderly residents, children, or pets.

Making the Best Choice for Your Home in Wausau and Beyond

Ultimately, the right fireplace for your Wisconsin home depends on your lifestyle, heating needs, aesthetic preferences, and budget. If you want powerful heat output, realistic flames, and are willing to invest in a more permanent installation, a gas fireplace installation might be your best bet. It’s a fantastic option for homeowners in Wausau who experience long, cold winters and desire a reliable, efficient heat source.

Conversely, if you value convenience, lower upfront costs, and flexible design choices, an electric fireplace may suit your needs better. It’s perfect for homeowners who prioritize simplicity and minimal maintenance, or who live in modern buildings without access to gas lines or chimneys.

Both gas and electric fireplaces can transform a room, adding warmth, charm, and visual appeal. As you weigh your options, consider how each type of fireplace aligns with your daily routines and long-term goals. Whether you’re remodeling a cozy cabin in northern Wisconsin or updating a downtown Wausau condo, the right fireplace can enhance your comfort and increase your home’s value for years to come.

Need Fireplace Professionals Near You?

Since 1949, we have been building, repairing, and renovating fireplaces all across Wisconsin for both commercial and residential locations. Our showroom offers a wide variety of fireplaces including accessories, fire pits, fire tables, and pellet style stoves. We even do stonework, chimneys, and mantles! With our full-service chimney sweep service, we can keep your fireplace prepared and safe. Marcell’s Specialties Inc. is available for either indoor or outdoor work, with the best equipment available. Give us a call or visit our showroom to have a member of our staff help you pick out the perfect piece for your home! We can even create a custom design based on your specifications!

Categorised in: Fireplaces

This post was written by admin